MENU

Gotham Steel

790 Votes
Rate this product
Gotham Steel Gotham Steel or Alternatives
Read Customer Reviews on Amazon.com

Gotham Steel is a non-stick frying pan that is made out of ceramic and durable titanium. Nothing will stick to this pan so you can stop wasting your time scraping. Food slides right out no matter what you are cooking. This piece of cookware can even go in the oven. Its durable exterior makes it tough and it will never scratch. No matter what you cook it will be loaded with flavor and healthier for you because Gotham Steel does not need any oil.
Customers are asking: Is this the same as the 'Red Copper Pan'???

Gotham Steel Gotham Steel or Alternatives
Read Customer Reviews on Amazon.com

Total Cost Breakdown

The cost of Gotham Steel is $19.99 plus $6.95 shipping. The special TV offer allows a free gift which you will receive by paying an extra fee of $6.95 for a total price of $33.89.

This price was obtained from the As Seen on TV commercial page which was taken offline due to Gotham Steel being discontinued. Gotham Steel may still be found for sale on Amazon or Ebay.

This price was obtained from the As Seen on TV commercial page which was taken offline due to Gotham Steel being discontinued. Gotham Steel may still be found for sale on Amazon or Ebay.

Features

  • Non-Stick Frying Pan

    Gotham Steel is a non-stick frying pan. It does not matter whether you are cooking eggs, steak or fish because nothing gets stuck in the pan.

  • Oven Safe

    This frying pan doubles over as a handy piece of cookware because it is oven safe up to 500 degrees. Now you can make delicious lasagna and casseroles without worrying about them sticking to the pan.

  • Nine Inches

    This pan has a diameter of nine inches.

  • Dishwasher Safe

    Clean up is just as easy because this pan is dishwasher safe.

  • Omelet Pan

    Every order also comes with an omelet pan. This pan lets you cook perfectly sized omelets that are loaded with your favorite ingredients. There is no flipping involved so you never have to worry about the omelet falling apart under your spatula.

Advantages

  • Never Scratches

    Gotham Steel will never scratch. Now you can whisk your eggs right into the frying pan without having to worry. You can even use an electric mixer.

  • Durable

    This frying pan is extremely durable. The infomercial shows it being hit with a meat cleaver and it does not crack or scratch.

  • Healthier

    You will automatically be eating healthier because this pan does not require any butter or oil no matter what you are cooking. Just add your ingredients directly to the pan. This decreases the number of calories you are consuming which is good for overall health and can aid in weight loss.

Save Money

When food gets stuck in pans it is sometimes impossible to get it off. You have to scrub at the pans which eventually cause scratches. Unfortunately, this sometimes leads to having to throw out your frying pans. This wastes your money because you are stuck buying new pans. Using Gotham Steel solves this problem because this frying pan will never scratch so you will not have to throw it out.

Save Time

When food gets stuck in your pans it takes forever to clean. You have to let your dishes soak and you spend endless time scrubbing away at them. Nothing sticks to Gotham Steel so you can save time. All you have to do is put it in the dishwasher, there is no scrubbing required.

Warnings

  • Do Not Use Cooking Spray

    Using nonstick cooking spray on nonstick cookware is a big no-no. Here's the problem with it — after a while your pan will get a sticky buildup of the spray that doesn't burn off during cooking. This usually happens around the sides of the pan.
    10 Ways to RUIN Non-Stick Pans

  • Washing Instructions

    1. Wash the pan with warm water and soap using a nylon scrubber.
    2. Rinse completely and dry with a soft cloth.
    Read on: Cleaning Non-Stick Pans

Infomercial

The Gotham Steel infomercial claims that nothing will stick to this pan and everything slides right out of it. During the infomercial, parmesan cheese is melted directly in the pan and it just slides right out. The same thing happened when a Smores dip was put in the oven. It was made up of chocolate chips, milk and marshmallows which are placed in the oven and the whole concoction slides right out of the pan. If you need even more convincing about this pan then here it is. Three peppermints are melted in the pan with their plastic wrappers on and they can be wiped right out of the pan - nothing sticks.

Cheapest Online:

CarolWrightGifts.com
Fry Pan 9.5" Diam. $19.99
Fry Pan 11" Diam. $29.99
Fry Pan 12.5" Diam. $39.99
9.5" Lid $9.99
11" Lid $12.99
12.5" Lid

$14.99

HarrietCarter.com
Fry Pan 9.5" Diam. $19.98
Fry Pan 11" Diam. $29.98
Fry Pan 12.5" Diam.

$39.98

Amazon
Fry Pan 9.5" Diam. $24.95
Fry Pan 12.5" Diam.

$129.99

GothamSteel.com
Fry Pan 9.5" Diam.

$19.99

TVStuffSale.com
Fry Pan 9.5" Diam. $19.95

GUARANTEED!
You Won't Find a Better Price

How Non-Stick Works

The most popular non-stick cookware surface consists of a thin layer of Teflon, also known as polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE). Recently health concerns have been raised over the use of PTFE, thus most manufactures duplicate its properties with an alternative fluoropolymer.

Gotham Steel Pans are PFOA and PFOS-free.

Regardless of what combination of materials, metals, or coatings a pan uses; they stop food from sticking to the surface is by preventing bonding at a molecular level. Such bonding naturally occurs under high-heat conditions.

Remember: Any pan will stick, it is the coating applied to the pan which prevents sticking.

Sticks After 9 Uses?

No! It does not stick after 9 uses. Truth be told, there is no magic number of times the pan can be used before losing its non-stick qualities. There have been a number of real customer reviews (as seen below) which state the pan stuck for them on the very first use; while others claim to have used the pan flawlessly for over a month. It's Not a Miracle Pan; you get what you pay for.

How to Season Gotham Steel Pan

It is commonly known that cast Iron pans need to be seasoned.

However, it is also recommended to season non-stick pans as well.

Nonstick coatings wear off with time. Seasoning will significantly help extend the life of nonstick pans!

Seasoning helps to fill in any pits or inconsistencies that have developed in the finish. Often times there exist blemishes which are invisible to the naked eye.

Most non-stick pans come pre-seasoned and ready for use; however, re-seasoning a pan will confirm that the process was conducted properly rather than relying on the process completed at mass by the factory.

What you'll need to season a non-stick pan:
- Water
- Teaspoon
- Paper towel
- Soap
- Cooking Oil
- Stove Top

Seasoning Instructions

  • Wash

    - Wash the pan using warm water with a mild dish soap. Do not scrub the pan.
    Ensure to use a soft, non-abrasive cloth.
    This will remove any particles or debris that could interfere with the seasoning process.

  • Dry

    - Thoroughly dry the pan with a clean paper towel. Ensure not to just move the water around into smaller areas.
    Continually switch to a new paper towel until you are able to wipe everywhere on the pan and absorb any water.

  • Heat

    - Place the pan on a stove top. Set the temperature to low for approximately 30 seconds.

  • Remove from Heat

    - Remove the pan from the heat source and turn off the stove top.

  • Add Oil

    - Measure-out one tablespoon of oil and pour it into the cooling / recently heated pan while it is still warm.
    - Cooking or vegetable oil is recommended specifically for non-stick cooking surfaces.
    - Gently spread the oil around the pan to evenly coat the entire surface.

  • Wait

    - Allow the oil to dry for several minutes. The oil will form a thick consistency once it cools down.

  • Repeat

    - Repeating this seasoning process every few months will help to maintain the pan's integrity.

Conclusion

  • Have realistic expectations.
  • Read real customer reviews, not just website reports.
  • Educate yourself on pan care.

With today's technology, most pans which cost between $20-$40 each will equally perform. As Seen on TV pans are no different. Pans such as Gotham Steel, Orgreenic, Red Copper, or Slip Stone all work great if they are properly cared for. Do not expect a $20 pan to be invincible, or last a lifetime.

Decide what you want:

a. If you want a pan that will last for years purchase the most expensive T-Fal set you can find; but don't expect your eggs to be sliding 'As Seen on TV'. Also, even T-Fal pans will quickly start to stick if they are not properly used and cared for.

b. If you want the As Seen on TV effect of a frying pan which appears as slick as ice; treat it properly, educate yourself on pan care and don't expect it to last a lifetime.

End State:
1. You get what you pay for.
2. The pan is worth the price.
3. Any cookware will fail if not cared for.

How it's Different from Competitors

Gotham Steel uses a combination of an ultra non-stick ceramic and super strong titanium to create a unique, durable and scratch resistant cooking surface.

Tips & Tricks

  1. 90 Day Guarantee

    This product is backed by a 90-day money back guarantee. If you are not totally satisfied with its performance, you are able to return Gotham Steel for your money back.

  2. Special Offer

    Gotham Steel is available in a special double offer. You may choose this option and you will get a second Gotham Steel fry pan for only a small fee.

Complaints

  1. False Advertising

    One customer complained that the product did not perform at all like it was advertised and that anything they tried to cook with Gotham Steel just ended up burning to the pan. Frustrated, they threw the pan in the trash.

  2. Doesn't Last

    There were several complaints that Gotham Steel lost its non-stick coating after being used several times.

    One customer claimed that they used the pan to cook pancakes. The first couple of pancakes, slide off with no problem; however, after that, they started to stick more and more with each use.

    It seems that this product's non-stick cooking fades once it has been heated a few times.

  3. Handle

    There was at least one complaint that a customer thought that Gotham Steel's handle was too small and said that they had difficulty holding the pan.

  4. Easily Scratched

    One customer claimed that the pan was easily scratched after using it only a few times.

  5. Waste of Money

    There are many bad reviews about this product claiming that it does not live up to its non-stick advertising. Many customers were disappointed with this product's performance and claimed to have thrown it in the trash.

  6. Warps

    There were several complaints that the Gotham Steel frying pan is very thin, flimsy and warps after a couple of uses.

  7. Hard to Clean

    There was at least one complaint where a customer stated that once the non-stick coating wore off, the pan became very hard to clean.

Alternatives

  • Zwilling Ceramic Non-stick Pan

    This is another similar non-stick frying pan. At just over nine inches in diameter, this durable pan with 3 ply construction is perfect for frying eggs without burning them.

    This pan features a flared rim for easy, non-drip pours and has a brushed stainless steel finish.

  • California Home Goods Pan

    This product also uses a durable titanium and ceramic fusion to provide you with an extra durable, non-stick cooking surface. It is scratch resistant and PTFE, PFOA, and PFOS free.

Critical Advice

Even though Gotham Steel is advertised as a non-stick frying pan, it is still a good idea to make sure that you are not cooking anything above the recommended temperature for that specific food. Always cook on the lowest possible setting that will still properly cook your food without burning it.

It is always a good idea to keep children out of the kitchen while you are cooking. This product should not be used by any children without adult supervision.

Wise Advice

Do not buy Gotham Steel online before searching Amazon.
- Alternatives or the same items are always available and sometimes at lower prices.

Wise Advice

Do not buy Gotham Steel online before searching Amazon.
- Alternatives or the same items are always available and sometimes at lower prices.

221 CUSTOMER REVIEWS ▼
WRITE REVIEW

Average Customer Rating:

1
Gotham Steel Reputation Management

Click to View

5 STARS
27
4 STARS
13
3 STARS
14
2 STARS
11
1 STARS
156

Sort: Newest | Helpful | Highest | Lowest

Type: All | Reviews | Questions | Comments

Posted: 21 Dec 2021 Dan - (West Haven, CT)

Don't Believe Ad

We bought a two pan set of fry pans at Costco last year and for the first use, I made scrambled eggs. The eggs stuck to the pan. Neither pan has lived up to its "non-stick" claims.

0 of 0 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 08 Feb 2021 christopher mohler - (Tipton, IN)

Junk Don't Buy

Got hosed again worked for about a week Wife said I love this pan great gift now she says this thing is a piece of crap I hate it get it out of my kitchen.

0 of 0 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 17 Dec 2020 carl caputo - (Venice, FL)

Trashed After 15 Uses

Have now trashed both frying pans as they both stick after maybe 15 uses. The commercial is not truthful or I received defective pans. I received these pans as a gift and did not know where to return or I would have. Scramble eggs are the worst. Shame on Gotham.

0 of 0 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 19 Jul 2020 Tammy Wilson - (Maple Grove, MN)

Burnt Pan

Save your money and your time. Don't buy these pans. Couldn't get a pancake out of the pan nor could I wash it or do the special cleaning.

0 of 0 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 10 Jul 2020 Robert Hoffman - (Nashville, TN)

Falsely Advertised as "non-stick"

Maintained exactly as recommended. Bought the entire set. My bad. Real rip off. Pans are well made physically, but definitely and not non-stick. That property goes away very quickly, if it ever existed, to begin with.

0 of 0 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 22 May 2020 Pat Howard - (Pittsburgh, PA)

Elderly User

Handles are very hard on old, arthritic hands. It would be nice to have an adapter to slide over the handle to stop it from digging into the hand. Pans are heavy adding to the discomfort.

0 of 0 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 05 May 2020 Sarah - (Guelph, ON)

Food Sticks Badly

Eggs, veggies, fish, chicken, beef. Everything sticks to these pans. Burn Marks impossible to remove. We bought these to protect our pet birds from PTFE fumes, but the "non-stick" feature is awful. It will actually ruin foods like fish because they stick so badly. I'm not sure how they can get away with advertising that it's non-stick.

0 of 0 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 29 Nov 2019 Patrick Weber - (Toronto, ON)

Sticking and Warping

Followed all instructions and after about a month the nonsticking gave up the warping started first time on the larger pan save your money buy cast iron the claims are false shame total crap.

0 of 0 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 15 Nov 2019 Nathan Champaigne - (Greater Sudbury, ON)

Gotham Steals Copper Bacon pan is Stained

Garbage.

0 of 0 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 03 Sep 2019 James primus - (Newark, NJ)

These pots and pans are useless they stick and scratch don't wast your money..

1 of 1 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 11 Aug 2019 BillieWillsey - (Inola, OK)

Worse Ever

I purchased these out of good faith that they do what we were shown. To bad this company doesn't make and sell what they advertise. Sorriest pans I have ever bought. Don't fall for it!

1 of 1 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 01 Aug 2019 Marilyn simmons - (Oneonta, AL)

Don't Work

I bought this and after about 2 months it sticks really bad.

1 of 1 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 17 May 2019 Deborah - (Pineville, LA)

Bought orgreenic pans but they ended up sticking so then I bought Gotham Steel. Also sticking. Now I am on the red copper. Does not look like it is going to be any better. Sure is not even worth buying.

3 of 3 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 12 May 2019 Cassandra - (New York, NY)

No Good!

I purchased the set in January 2019. Used this frying pan for the first time today and it stuck to the pan and now the pan is damaged. They only have 30 return policy and can not find any way to return or exchange this defective pan. I am so disappointed!

3 of 4 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 20 Apr 2019 John - (Winston-Salem, NC)

Waste Of Money

Had it for abourt 2 months. Just fried some chicken in it last night. Soaking overnight and scrubbing with sponge = mess still on pan.

3 of 3 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 09 Apr 2019 Daniel - (Saint-Quentin, NB)

Sticks

It does stick after a few uses. No lies, no fake news. It just sticks. Dan.

4 of 4 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 20 Mar 2019 Peter Van Horn IV - (Lawrence, KS)

It Sticks Worse Than a Regular Pan!

I got the pan and tried to cook an egg. It stuck so bad I couldn't even flip it. I had to scramble it up just to get it out of the pan. Then I read that you have to season the pan (I would like to have known that before buying, because I like to wash with soap) and it burned oil on the pan so badly that it now won't come off. I've had the pan for like 45 min. Worst product ever.

3 of 3 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 14 Feb 2019 Lorinne - (Nanaimo, BC)

Must now use non Stick Spray Every Use!

My husband's daughter gave us two frying pans, one small, the other large. Not only does the non-stick fail within months (used for eggs, stir fry, pancakes, french toast, and grilled sandwiches) when used several times a week, it is now impossible to even get it completely clean. Only silicone, soft plastic or wood utensils used, never used above medium, never put in the oven, and washed with plain dish soap and water. The coating is not scratched or Marred in any way, but this is no longer even close to a non-stick pan - even pancakes stick if not sprayed between EACH pancake, and in some cases, between flips of the same pancake. The large frypan has actually lost its flat bottom, and cups upwards by several millimetres. Now that it has lost its non-stick properties this is an issue as any oil or grease used runs to the outer rim, and does not keep the centre lubricated. Actually frying noodles or eggs is a joke, unless practically deep fried in oil, they will stick, even non-stick spray is no longer doing the trick with these items. This is also why they no longer come clean, and even when forced to use a "Scrub Daddy" or green sheet scrubby, it is no longer a completely clean or pristine pan, on the interior - it is covered with dark flecks, particularly along the raised interior portion (pan lip), where it is impossible to keep it greased. For what we paid, and how it was touted, this is a rip-off. No better than any other non-stick pan. Good for a few months at best.

7 of 7 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 08 Feb 2019 Doug Farrow - (Aurora, ON)

Gotham Steel fry pan

Was totally disappointed in this fry pan. As far as I am concerned it is false advertising they use. Food stuck on second use and I noticed scratches in the coding after two or three uses. Kept using it and it just got worse. Garbage don't buy it.

3 of 3 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 30 Jan 2019 James Dawson - (Kansas City, MO)

Shame on False Advertising

I have tried 4 different pans. All could not pass the one-time use test. 2nd-time food was beginning to stick. By the fourth time, it was just like any other pan. Worthless. Don't get suckered into buying them.

4 of 4 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 25 Jan 2019 grant m ayjian - (Midlothian, VA)

Gothem rip off

This product purchased at Walmart, had me trying to remove eggs that stuck to the pan, it is not worth the money and is a rip-off. Please let Walmart check on this and test it themselves, I would have more fun throwing my 20. 00 out the window an watch it floats away. Do not buy this product.

5 of 7 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 21 Dec 2018 Scott Gagnon - (Groveland, MA)

The Coating Came off

Just after one use the coating came off you said it was indestructible sorry your wrong.

3 of 3 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 21 Dec 2018 Bill - (Placerville, CA)

Cast Iron Proves to Still be Best!

Bought one for myself and one for a friend after watching the advertisement, can't go wrong, right? Wrong. Money back guarantee, can't go wrong, right? Wrong again. Neither new pan worked as it did on the tv advertisement. Not even close. Tried to re-season the pans but unless I cooked right over the oil or butter everything, I mean everything stuck. Eggs did ok if I had oil in the pan, did a side by side comparison with my 50-year-old cast iron pan. Cast iron won easily. Oh and the money back thing they lie about? How do they get away with this rip-off? They do make for a good target for sighting in guns though. Fyi, bullets do not stick to the pan. This was such a rip-off, and they do not honor the money back guarantee. I suggest go get grandma's cast iron skillet. They still work best in any situation!

7 of 7 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 01 Dec 2018 BELINDA GRIMES - (United States, US)

Useless

This was the biggest rip off. My pans scratched and food stuck after a few uses. Now I'm stuck with them.

6 of 6 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply

Posted: 13 Nov 2018 Xena - (Edmonton, AB)

These pans are garbage and I would like a full refund, how do I go about getting it? Thank you.

4 of 4 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Reply

Write Your Reply



Submit Review, Comment or Question ▼
- - - - Not Required For Comments & Questions
*Optional
*Optional

Reviews, Comments & Questions Help Everyone
Your Opinion Counts!

It Works!

Gotham Steel Infomercial

Slides Across Pan

Gotham Steel Infomercial

QVC

Gotham Steel Infomercial

User Notification

Please click 'Allow' then 'Allow' to receive notifications of new As Seen on TV items, Review Videos, and contest giveaways. You can change your mind at any time and disable notifications.

ALLOW
NO THANKS

TV Stuff Reviews is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

NEXT AS SEEN ON TV ITEM ▼